The Oyez Project Virtual Tour of the Supreme Court Building

Abstract

Argument: Monday, April 15, 1996
Decision: Thursday, June 20, 1996
Issues: Economic Activity, Governmental Liability

Advocates

Beth S. Brinkmann (Argued the cause for the respondent)
Walter A. Smith, Jr. (Argued the cause for the petitioner)

Facts of the Case

The Department of Transportation expelled Lane, a student, from the U.S. Merchant Marine Academy because he was diagnosed with diabetes. Lane sued the Department of Transportation alleging that his termination violated section 504 of the 1973 Rehabilitation Act, which barred "any program or activity under any executive agency" from discriminating on the basis of disability. The district court reinstated Lane, but refused to award damages because the federal government's sovereign immunity had not been waived by Congress. The appeals court affirmed the district court decision.

Question

Did Congress waive the federal government's sovereign immunity against monetary damages with respect to section 504(a) of the 1973 Rehabilitation Act?

Conclusion

No. Although the related provisions of the 1973 Rehabilitation Act and the 1991 Civil Rights Act might in combination be read as waiving the federal government's sovereign immunity, absent an unambiguous waiver of sovereign immunity, the court cannot permit damages to be awarded.

Supreme Court Justice Opinions and Votes (by Seniority)

Sort by Ideology
(More information here)
Decision: 7 votes for Pena, 2 vote(s) against
Legal Provision: Rehabilitation
Voted with the majority
Rehnquist
Wrote a dissent
Stevens
Wrote the majority opinion
O'Connor
Voted with the majority
Scalia
Voted with the majority
Kennedy
Voted with the majority
Souter
Voted with the majority
Thomas
Voted with the majority
Ginsburg
Voted with the minority, joined Stevens' dissent
Breyer
Full Opinion by Justice Sandra Day O'Connor

Cite this page

The Oyez Project, Lane v. Pena, 518 U.S. 187 (1996),
available at: <http://www.oyez.org/cases/1990-1999/1995/1995_95_365/>
(last visited ).