Hodgson v. Minnesota

Media Items
Hodgson v. Minnesota - Oral Argument
Get Adobe Flash Player
Advocates
Janet Benshoof (Argued the cause for Hodgson)
John R. Tunheim (Chief Deputy Attorney General of Minnesota argued the cause for Minnesota)
Case Basics
Docket No.: 
88-1125
Petitioner: 
Hodgson
Respondent: 
Minnesota
Consolidation: 
Minnesota et al. v. Hodgson et al., No. 88-1309
Opinion: 
497 U.S. 417 (1990)
Categories: 
abortion
Location No location information present.

Cite this page
The Oyez Project, Hodgson v. Minnesota , 497 U.S. 417 (1990)
available at: (http://oyez.org/cases/1980-1989/1989/1989_88_1125)
Facts of the Case: 

Under Section 2 of a Minnesota statute regulating a minor's access to abortion, women under 18 were denied access to the procedure until 48 hours after both their parents had been notified. Exceptions were made in the cases of medical emergencies and women who were victims of parental abuse. Section 6 of the law allowed the courts to judicially bypass Section 2 if the young woman could maturely demonstrate that notification would be unwise.

Question: 

Did the Minnesota abortion notification statute unconstitutionally restrict a minor's access to having an abortion?

Conclusion: 

The Court found Section 2 of the statute unconstitutional because requiring notification of both parents, whether or not both wanted to know or had taken responsibility for raising the child, did not serve a legitimate state interest. The Court favored notification of only one parent and a 48 hour waiting period. The Court upheld Section 6 of the law.

Decisions

Decision: 5 votes for Minnesota, 4 vote(s) against
Legal provision: Due Process

Sort by Ideology

Voted with the majority, joined Kennedy's concurrence
Rehnquist
Voted with the minority, joined Marshall's dissent
Brennan
Voted with the majority, joined Kennedy's concurrence
White
Wrote a dissent
Marshall
Voted with the minority, joined Marshall's dissent
Blackmun
Wrote a dissent
Stevens
Wrote a special concurrence
O'Connor
Wrote a special concurrence, joined Kennedy's concurrence
Scalia
Wrote a special concurrence
Kennedy

Full Opinion by Justice John Paul Stevens

Timeplots Affiliate

Timeplots.com: A Visual History of the Supreme Court