The Oyez Project Virtual Tour of the Supreme Court Building

Abstract

Oral Argument: Wednesday, January 19, 1977
Decision: Monday, March 7, 1977
Issues: Economic Activity, State Tax

Advocates

James H. Haddock (Argued the cause for the appellee)
Alan W. Perry (Argued the cause for the appellant)

Facts of the Case

Complete Auto Transit was a Michigan corporation doing business in Mississippi. Complete shipped cars into the state where they were distributed for sale. Mississippi imposed a tax on transportation companies for the "privilege of doing business" in the state. The tax was applied equally to businesses involved in intra- and interstate commerce.

Question

Did the Mississippi tax violate the Commerce Clause because it placed a burden on an activity associated with interstate commerce?

Conclusion

A unanimous Court found the tax valid. Businesses involved in interstate commerce should assume a just share of the state tax burden. The Court's decision established four criteria to be met for a state tax to be valid and not an unreasonable burden on interstate commerce. The tax must be (1) on an activity connected to the state, (2) fairly apportioned to be based on intrastate commerce, (3) nondiscriminatory, and (4) related to state services provided. These criteria are only valid if Congress has not imposed conflicting regulations.

Supreme Court Justice Opinions and Votes (by Ideology)

Sort by Seniority
(More information here)
Full Opinion: Economic Activity, State Tax: 9 - 0
Voted with the majority, joined Blackmun's opinion
Brennan
Voted with the majority, joined Blackmun's opinion
Marshall
Voted with the majority, joined Blackmun's opinion
Stevens
Voted with the majority, joined Blackmun's opinion
White
Voted with the majority, joined Blackmun's opinion
Stewart
Voted with the majority, authored an opinion
Blackmun
Voted with the majority, joined Blackmun's opinion
Powell
Voted with the majority, joined Blackmun's opinion
Burger
Voted with the majority, joined Blackmun's opinion
Rehnquist

Cite this page

The Oyez Project, Complete Auto Transit Inc. v. Brady, 430 U.S. 274 (1977),
available at: <http://www.oyez.org/cases/1970-1979/1976/1976_76_29/>
(last visited ).